The animals create a fake commercial for a fake event to drive the farmer out of town so that the gang can celebrate Otis' birthday, but trouble arises when Snotty Boy is hired to watch the barn, and he torments the animals nonstop. So the animals must find a way to get rid of him.
- Chris Hardwick as Otis
- Leigh-Allyn Baker as Abby
- Jeffrey Garcia as Pip
- Cam Clarke as Freddy
- Rob Paulsen as Peck / Reginald Beady
- Tino Insana as Pig
- Wanda Sykes as Bessy
- Dom Irrera as Duke
- Maria Bamford as Nora Beady
- Steve Oedekerk as Nathan Randall Beady III / Snotty Boy
- Fred Tatasciore as the Farmer
- The title of this episode is a parody of the film The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly.
- After the animals roll out of the barn after Snotty Boy glued them together, Bessy complains because Peck is glued to her butt. But just before this, Peck is seen lying far away from Bessy.